Attorney Franz Borghardt joined Mornings With Brian Haldane to go through the legal angles in the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie. The case continues to draw national attention. Pima County deputies expanded their search over the weekend. They also followed new leads and released another public plea for information.
If She Went Missing on Her Own
Borghardt first outlined the simplest path. If Guthrie walked away on her own and had a medical emergency, no crime occurred. But anyone who used that moment to send a fake ransom note would face charges. That would fall under fraud and other financial crimes. “You also make yourself a suspect,” he said. “You put yourself near the scene.”
If Kidnapping Occurred
If investigators confirm a kidnapping, the stakes rise fast. A death during a kidnapping triggers the felony murder rule. Intent does not matter. Even an unrelated medical issue can lead to a murder charge if it happens during the crime. Borghardt also noted that withholding needed medication makes the situation worse. That still counts as contributing to a death.
If It Was an Inside Job
Public speculation has focused on the people close to Guthrie. Borghardt said the law treats insiders and strangers the same. “The most serious charge is still kidnapping and possible murder,” he explained. Extra charges, such as obstruction or fraud, may follow. But they do not change the top charge.
The Problem With Online Detectives
Borghardt warned about the rush of amateur investigators online. They often act without real information. In past cases, this has led to false accusations. He pointed to examples from the Boston Marathon investigation.
Will She Be Found?
Borghardt believes investigators will eventually locate Guthrie. Modern forensic tools, digital tracking, and common mistakes made by offenders support that view. The concern now is her condition when she is found.
