Will Louisiana Get Rid of State Income Tax?

Louisiana has been grappling with the question of whether to eliminate its state income tax. The proposal to do so has sparked heated debates among lawmakers, citizens, and experts. Let’s delve into the details with Mary Robinson of Advantage Consulting. 

The Proposal

House Bill 414, a 25-page constitutional amendment, aimed to abolish the state income tax. Sponsored by Rep. Richard Nelson, R-Mandeville, the bill outlined several significant changes. These included raising state sales taxes, reducing the homestead property tax exemption, phasing out the Industrial Tax Exemption Program, and trimming funding for hospitals. The goal was to offset the cost of eliminating the income tax and enhance Louisiana’s business climate.

The Debate

  1. Education and Health Care Impact: Legislators expressed concerns about the proposal’s impact on public education, health care, and the poor. The reduction in funding for K-12 education (through the Minimum Foundation Program) raised alarm bells. Rep. Buddy Mincey, R-Denham Springs, pointed out that wealthier parishes currently receive more education funding due to higher property tax values. Eliminating the income tax could lead to a billion-dollar cut in education funding.
  2. Homestead Exemption: Rep. Laurie Schlegel, R-Metairie, supported the idea of eliminating the income tax but acknowledged that about 75% of her constituents opposed it. Their primary concern was the reduction in the homestead exemption from $75,000 to $25,000. The current exemption shields the first $75,000 of a home’s value from local property taxes.
  3. Population Growth and Taxes: Rep. Nelson argued that eliminating the income tax would make Louisiana more competitive. He cited that four of the ten fastest-growing states lacked an income tax. However, research on the direct impact of taxes on population rates remains inconclusive. Washington, D.C., with a high income tax rate, experienced a 14% population increase according to the 2020 census.

The Future

While the proposal was temporarily shelved, the debate continues. Louisiana Revenue Secretary Richard Nelson indicated that Governor Jeff Landry aims to set the stage for eventually eliminating the income tax, starting in 2025. However, whether this will happen in one dramatic step or through gradual changes remains uncertain12.

In the end, the decision will hinge on balancing economic competitiveness, education funding, and the well-being of Louisiana’s residents.

Back To Archive